Interview: Estonia's Man in Moscow Comes Home (9)

Krister Paris Photo: ERR
7/4/2013 12:00 PM
Category: Features

After five years as the Moscow correspondent of Estonian Public Broadcasting, Krister Paris returned to Estonia just in time for the midsummer holiday. Ott Tammik, an editor at ERR News, caught up with Paris to talk about his firsthand experiences and recent changes in Estonian-Russian relations.

What has changed in the five years that you've been in Moscow?

There was a clear development in the mentality of people, I would say a positive development.

When I arrived, Putin and his supporters were firmly in power. A few years ago, if some were to yell "retire Putin" at a protest, it would have come as a complete shock. And now it is totally normal to criticize the government.

The change in mentality is not only political, but the population in general has become more Western and European, especially Moscow. People dress better and they are more aware. The middle class has become wealthier and is traveling abroad more often. It seems that people are more often looking for a trash can to throw their garbage in and there is a certain caring that I didn't see before. There are all kinds of citizen initiatives. There is a massive inertia, it is a massive country and a massive capital city.

You've said that the political environment has reminded you of your childhood memories of the Singing Revolution?

Absolutely. The explosion and the feeling of freedom when people took to the streets and understood suddenly that there were many of them. And the authorities retreated at first.

In the beginning political activeness was almost non-existent. Street protests were made up of a few hundred people, which is ridiculous for Moscow. Then came the breakthrough; something clicked when the authorities said that Putin was here to stay regardless of the nation's will.

When I went to Bolotnaya Square at one of the first major demonstrations in December 2011 there were suddenly, to everyone's surprise, no longer hundreds or thousands of people, but tens and later hundreds of thousands of people. Suddenly everything seemed possible. Something seemed to be changing and the powers seemed to be panicking and there was a vibrant discussion on the internet. The magic was in the fact that it consolidated everyone. At some point gays and skinheads were standing together on the square; it galvanized all layers of society.

Why did it dissipate?

It turned out that there wasn't the critical mass - 100,000 people is just 1 percent of Moscow. Since it was a spontaneous movement, the demonstrators lacked any kind of common goal other than to force Putin out.

They didn't know what to do next and they didn't find a leader.

And on one hand it was all limited to Moscow, which, as the capital, has shown the rest of Russia the way, but everyone else continued to watch their televisions.

Most of the leaders have now been hit with criminal cases and are going to court, although no one has really been arrested yet. Then came the Bolotnaya case, where the government sent a clear message that not only leaders but everyone who supports them can be put behind bars.

Now we see that the authorities have put the squeeze on the opposition, and after a while it became pointless to do stories about subsequent arrests and restrictive new laws.

When can we expect new changes?

I have talked to analysts who have said that they think the powers will do everything possible to ensure that the Olympic Games go peacefully. Let's say that in 18 months or two years, when the games have smoothly passed, they will have to start making tough decisions.

So Putin won't stay forever?

It may seem for now that there is no sign of a successor for Putin. They tried it with Medvedev and the Kremlin saw it as a failure.

Putin's problem is that he is part of what's know as the Collective Putin. He doesn't have any other choice but to remain until he is told to. He is serving a life sentence because the people who are pumping oil and pocketing the proceeds won't let him go. He is the face of the regime and the only one that has not been discredited and who cannot be criticized in the state media. The only thing the Kremlin cares about is holding onto power at all costs. At first they will not go over dead bodies, because that could be damaging. If blood were to seriously flow somewhere, the result would be unpredictable. They have been very smart so far, putting on some pressure but nothing like the brutality seen in Belarus.

Life has shown that these kinds of revolutions usually occur unexpectedly and from some kind of ostensibly unimportant event, such as when the man who lit himself on fire triggered the Arab Spring. In Russia's case, there is an interesting phenomenon in which the improvement of the nation's quality of life could spell the end for the Putinist regime.

Is Estonia a gathering place for Russia's political opposition?

It is my understanding that it is to some extent. They also go to Lithuania, but there is purportedly a much greater presence of Russian intelligence workers there. I can't really say how often they come here, but from time to time there have been media reports that they are meeting here again.

I heard that one of the members of Voina (a street art group) lives in Tartu. They were responsible for drawing a giant phallus on the Liteyny drawbridge facing the headquarters of the FSB in St. Petersburg. I heard it was quite impressive when they raised it in the evening.

But in all seriousness, Estonia is a role model for the opposition, and for the more awakened people in general. It is the West, it is liberal, it is everything that Russia is not. Estonia has in their eye taken a cardinally different direction. There is no other former USSR country that is as successful today. The Baltics are all more or less the same, but it could be argued that Estonia is the most successful thanks to its lower level of corruption.

And does the average citizen believe that?

Yes. There are two types of people. One is of the older generation, for whom Estonia is a nostalgic place. Many have come here for honeymoons and they remember Soviet Estonia as a charming place and they have a soft spot for it. And then there is the younger generation, who come to Estonia because their wallet might now permit them to travel farther or because people here speak Russian but have a completely different mentality. Estonia has a good reputation and all the efforts to change that - whether regarding the Bronze Soldier or whatever - have faded into the background.

So the Bronze Soldier affair is in the past?

Absolutely. Sometimes the Kremlin decides that for some internal political reason it needs to beat on someone else and draw attention elsewhere. But Estonia is in no way an everyday topic of conversation. Size-wise it is like one district of Moscow, if that.

The keener people understand that that which is shown on television about other countries has just as much truth as the domestic affairs being covered. But beliefs outside of Moscow can be completely different. Of course, the propaganda is very skillful. There is never a blatant lie. Every fact they assert can be signed off on, but it's more about how they are presented.

You covered the recent thaw in Estonian-Russian border treaty negotiations. How did that come about?

Russia tried hard to pretend it was not their initiative, which it was. Lavrov tried out the idea in an annual speech at a university where he has been know to test the waters. I asked Lavrov at a press conference why they had suddenly changed their minds. We have the same government as before and now suddenly they show an interest in improving relations with us. Of course the answer was: "No, it was your initiative. We have always said that we are ready to go forward if you are willing to make concessions."

But clearly there have been some signs for a while. The Bronze Soldier affair practically ended all transit through Estonia and it was clearly political. When I first went to TransRussia, a major annual conference, the transit businessmen said things were very bad. Later things were developing quietly and trains were rolling again, but insiders didn't want to talk about it at all because they feared that if someone who does not want good relations heard about it, they might pick up the phone and shut it down again. And this year, suddenly, there was a big Estonian exhibition, and Anne Veski [an Estonian singer popular in Russia] even showed up.

Why the change of heart?

Analysts say Russia wants to get its past problems out of the way. They just want to repair international relations. They have unsigned border treaties only with Estonia and Japan. It is a practical step and they have come to understand that there is no point in continuing endless historical debates. Also, they need it if they want to move forward with the proposed EU-Russia visa freedom plans.

Do they really need the border treaty for a visa-free policy?

No, practically speaking they don't, but it is still better if there are no directly hostile countries at the negotiating table. They no longer see a reason to pick pointless fights with all their neighbors, especially in Europe. Poland is the best example. There have not been any tangible breakthroughs, but they have made gestures to ease tensions.

And how has the Estonian side responded?

Look at the change in rhetoric of the shapers of our foreign policy. If you compared the language of Ansip or Mihkelson a few years ago and today, it would seem that they aren't the same people.

Critics of the border treaty developments say that Estonia is giving everything away.

Well look at what prompted the thaw in relations. Estonia gave up everything and Russia didn't take a single step back. It is without doubt the result of pressure from businessmen. I wouldn't say that we have completely sold out. But let's say that Russia has come to understand that soft power works better than direct conflict when seeking to keep someone in their sphere of influence, or to expand it.

In what other areas could Estonia and Russia see eye to eye?

The next step is to join the Commonwealth of Independent States [laughs]. Our values are clearly conflicting [...] Certainly businessmen would know to propose concrete agreements for business to flow more smoothly. Another important reform of great symbolic value would be to implement a humane - that is to say, onboard - passport control system on the Tallinn-Moscow train routes so that trains don't have to wait on the border for two hours. There are also all kinds of visa simplification issues that I believe would be in both countries' interests.

Does Russia still pose a military threat to Estonia?

We have no reason to fear Russian tanks. From time to time, when this issue again arises in Estonia, and I have asked Russian analysts for input, they look at me with a face that seems to say they feel slightly sorry for me - "what are you talking about?" they ask. The threat to Russia is from the south and in the longer term from China. they have good relations with the West, even with Estonia. The West is more likely a partner. If they want to have some form of influence over us, it is easier to buy us out - let's be direct, through politicians.

What shocked you most in Russia?

I went there with a really open mind, so I wasn't really expecting anything. Freedoms have been taken away step by step, not with a single bang. The government has taken advantage of the people and their uncertainty, as was the case in the Chechen war. The government used fear tactics just as our politicians do.

And the level of corruption was appalling of course. I saw how it suffocated the people. It's no wonder that the share of young people going into entrepreneurship is something like 2 percent. You can never be sure that your business won't be taken away from you, or officials might demand such a high bribe that you are forced to shut down. Or perhaps you get into a car accident with an important official. It's not about one specific event, but the general feeling of what it means to live in a closed and unfree society which has continued to deteriorate into deeper authoritarianism.

I think one of the best symbols from Russia was how during Putin's inauguration his motorcade drove through completely empty streets, and in the background somewhere you may have seen the the military vehicles that kept crowds away. And compare that with the number of people who welcomed Obama.


The name field cannot be empty
No more than 50 characters
Comment field cannot be empty
No more than 50 characters
Comment field cannot be empty
No more than 1024 characters
{{error}}

Message forwarded to the editor

This Ip-address has limited access

See also

There are no comments yet. Be the first!

Reply to comment

+{{childComment.ReplyToName}}:
Reply to comment
Reply

Laadi juurde ({{take2}})
The name field cannot be empty
No more than 50 characters
Comment field cannot be empty
No more than 1024 characters
{{error}}
Add new comment
  • foto
    Gallery: Tartu students mark 97th anniversary of Estonian-language university
    01.12

    While the University of Tartu in its earliest form was established in 1632, Estonian did not become the official language of instruction until Dec. 1, 1919. Today, the anniversary of the Estonian-language university is celebrated annually with a number of traditional events, the most visible of which is a torchlight procession through town involving dozens of student organizations and hundreds of students and alumni.

  • foto
    Gallery: Tartu students mark 97th anniversary of Estonian-language university
    01.12

    While the University of Tartu in its earliest form was established in 1632, Estonian did not become the official language of instruction until Dec. 1, 1919. Today, the anniversary of the Estonian-language university is celebrated annually with a number of traditional events, the most visible of which is a torchlight procession through town involving dozens of student organizations and hundreds of students and alumni.

  • foto
    Supposed tourism farm turned country home: Ilves’ Ermamaa builds farm with EU support, never puts it to intended use
    21.10

    Former president Toomas Hendrik Ilves’ company received €190,392 in 2006 to turn the family’s country home of Ärma into a tourism farm. Then owned by his ex-wife, it negotiated new conditions in 2012: Even if the farm was never put to its intended use, the company would have to pay back just 10% of the grant.

  • foto
    Feature: Is Germany Estonia’s new benchmark?
    19.10

    With the United Kingdom leaving the European Union, Estonia will have to look for a new great partner in Europe. Some have indicated that it could be Germany — yet just at the time it could become more important to Estonia, Europe's economic powerhouse is facing events that may well lead to a much more Russia-friendly course, writes historian Jeroen Bult.

  • foto
    Experts: President Ilves put Estonia on the map
    10.10

    With president-elect Kersti Kaljulaid’s oath of office at 3:00 p.m. today Monday, President Toomas Hendrik Ilves’ remarkable decade as Estonia’s head of state will end. ETV’s “Aktuaalne Kaamera Nädal” weekly review asked social scientists and policy experts what would remain of Ilves’ presidency.

  • foto
    Interview with Junior Achievement mentor: On Estonia's student companies
    18.09

    In a written interview given to ERR News, veteran Junior Achievement student mentor Madis Vodja, a Tallinn native who was most recently mentor to Junior Achievement Estonia's 2016 winning student company Spoony, provided insight into what Junior Achievement is, what the program's mentors do, how Estonian student companies can compete for national and European titles as well as a bit of advice for aspiring student or small business-owners in Estonia.

  • foto
    Estonia's six Paralympians in Rio
    18.09

    The 2016 Summer Paralympics in Rio de Janeiro, which also mark the 15th Summer Paralympic Games and the first to be hosted in South America, are drawing to a close on Sunday night after over a week and a half of competition. Estonia was represented in Rio by a six-athlete team which headed to the Games with a number of titles and medals, including Paralympic gold, already under its collective belt.

  • foto
    Interview with Marina Kaljurand: On taxes, corruption, the justice system and refugee policy
    17.09

    Presidential hopeful Marina Kaljurand told ERR's online news portal in a written interview that she is a liberal in worldview, who supports lower taxes on employment and bigger investments in higher education, is in favor of the state borrowing only if absolutely necessary and with great caution, and does not consider Estonia's current refugee policy to be remotely shameful.

  • foto
    Estonia’s information society development from a privacy and data protection perspective
    16.09

    Today Estonia has the most technologically advanced government system the world has seen. Even though the small Baltic state yields a population of only 1.3 million, it is known for its e-government system that has everyone applying to be an e-resident of Estonia, even the Japanese Prime Minister.

  • foto
    Original Estonian flag delivered to new permanent home at national museum
    15.09

    Previously only removed from storage for public display on rare special occasions, the original blue, black and white Estonian flag, consecrated on June 4, 1884 as the flag of the Estonian Students' Society (EÜS), was ceremonially delivered to the new Estonian National Museum (ERM) building on Thursday, where it will be put on permanent display as part of an exhibit on the founding and formation of the Estonian identity and state.

  • foto
    Pealtnägija: Common-sense approach to offering specialized medical treatment could save millions
    15.09

    ETV’s investigative magazine “Pealtnägija” reported on Wednesday that while there is a gaping hole in the Health Insurance Fund’s finances, millions could be saved by avoiding that specialist medical procedures are performed more often than necessary.

  • foto
    Reflections of an “Esto”: Estonia in 1975 and 2016
    03.09

    Anne Sarapik, the New York City-born daughter of two war-era Estonian refugees and mother of four Estonian-American children born during the final years of Estonia’s occupation by the USSR, visited her family’s homeland this summer after a long absence, discovering a vastly different Estonia than she remembered from her first visit in 1975.

  • foto
    Margus Laidre: The utopia of peace and the flowers of evil
    22.08

    Do you believe that if you close your eyes, evil ceases to exist? Although terrorism and war scar our world, many believe that we are nevertheless living in the most peaceful time we’ve known. Historian and diplomat Margus Laidre demonstrates in his essay that this may prove to be a dangerous illusion.

  • foto
    Eight former prime ministers talk about Estonia’s 25 years of regained independence
    20.08

    A quarter of a century has passed since Estonia regained its independence. On the occasion, ERR interviewed all of the country’s eight former prime ministers: Edgar Savisaar, Tiit Vähi, Mart Laar, Andres Tarand, Mart Siiman, Siim Kallas, Juhan Parts, and Andrus Ansip.

  • foto
    From hobby brewer to brewmaster in Estonia's flourishing craft beer scene
    24.07

    Not yet even out of his late 20s, up-and-coming Estonian brewer Peeter Kolk made the jump from brewing for fun and for friends to making a serious go of contributing to the country’s ever more popular craft beer scene with the establishment of his own Kolk Brewery in Uuemõisa, just outside of the western coastal town of Haapsalu in Lääne County, in early 2016.

  • foto
    An old publication's new tricks: How an Estonian-American newspaper is compiled from Tallinn
    23.07

    Over half a century before the arrival of the Internet and social media, it was an Estonian-language newspaper published in Manhattan, the Vaba Eesti Sõna, or "Free Estonian Word," founded in 1949, which kept the Estonian-American diaspora connected and up to date on news from both home and the Soviet-occupied homeland. Nearly 70 years later, the paper's official editorial office remains located on the third floor of the New York Estonian House, but in modern e-Estonia style, editor-in-chief Kärt Ulman has been putting the weekly paper together from her home in Tallinn for three years.

  • foto
    ‘That Dutchman’: Why Peter Kentie’s brand proposal for Estonia should be taken very seriously
    17.07

    What Estonia has in common with the Dutch city of Eindhoven, why Kentie was the right man to create its new brand, and what will happen if those in charge aren’t kept from bungling it: Here is the long story of “Just estonishing”.

  • foto
    What can Western governments do to counteract radicalization?
    16.07

    You can’t kill a thought with a bullet. You can only defeat it with a stronger thought. As attacks continue, and the unrelenting effort and billions invested in the global war on terrorism haven’t brought results, the question arises what individual governments can do to curb the emergence of radical Islamism.

  • foto
    Interview: Pavlo Klimkin says Russia at war with both Ukraine and EU
    22.06

    What got Ukraine where it is today? Who is responsible for the mistakes of the past 25 years? What’s the oligarchs’ role in politics? ETV+ talked to Ukrainian foreign minister Pavlo Klimkin. Here is the full-length video interview in English.

  • foto
    Feature: The world's scariest dress rehearsal
    20.06

    On Sunday NATO member forces rehearsed for the final staged battle of the 2016 Sabre Strike exercise. The demonstration is to take place today in the Estonian Defence Forces' central training area close to Tapa in Lääne-Viru County. As artillery, anti-tank units, infantry, and air support unloaded their guns, Nicholas Marsh stood on "TV Hill" and watched in awe.

  • foto
    Trust your neighbor, pay less? The future of electricity production in Estonia
    18.06

    Historically, Estonia has exported electricity. The country’s policy to guarantee production capacity at 110% of its peak consumption as well as the remnants of its formerly state-run production system have made this possible. But the market and its conditions are changing.

  • foto
    Varnja: The people and potential on the shores of Lake Peipus
    12.06

    In a village of just 250 residents on the western, Estonian shore of the fifth-largest lake in Europe, known as Peipus ('Peipsi järv') in Estonian and Chudskoe in Russian, a mix of old blood and new — Russian-speakers and Estonians, Old Believers and newcomers — live and work side by side. Despite any differences, however, Varnja's residents have at least one thing in common: their belief in the village's potential.

  • foto
    Timmermans: EU needs to show it can deliver
    16.05

    First Vice President of the European Commission Frans Timmermans was a panelist at the 10th Lennart Meri Conference in Tallinn that ended on Sunday. In an interview with ERR's Neeme Raud, he said that the EU needed to show that it was making progress, and to explain more, so people could see its value.

  • foto
    Young immigrants' dream to marry European girls harder and harder to realize
    10.05

    ”Marry a beautiful European girl. I'm planning to do that as well,” Mohammed, a 25-year-old asylum seeker, says to his closest friend as they are drinking tea in the restaurant of one of the hotels turned refugee reception centers in Athens.

  • foto
    May 9: Europe Day for some, Victory Day for others
    09.05

    While the European Union celebrates Europe Day on May 9, in Russia it is Victory Day. This collision of holidays affects Tallinn, where pro-Putin activists of the group Nochnoy Dozor have called for a march through the city center.

  • foto
    Estonia’s great private schools debate: to fund or not to fund
    05.04

    A recently submitted letter of appeal co-signed by 75 leading figures of Estonian academia, culture and society in support of the country’s private schools has sparked a fierce new round of debates regarding a stalled bill proposing an amendment to an unconstitutional law which would release local governments from being required to fund the operational costs of private schools.

  • foto
    Estonians host five-day cultural festival in the heart of Manhattan
    28.03

    The New York Estonian community recently hosted its annual Estonian Cultural Days in NYC (“Eesti Kultuuripäevad New Yorgis”), a multi-day affair with concerts, theater performances, lectures, and other events spanning five days from March 23-27 and featuring Estonians from both the local diaspora and abroad.

  • foto
    National Language Day celebrated by Estonian youth around the world
    14.03

    Despite differences in number of students, fluency, budget, distance, and other constraints, Estonian Schools as well as kindergartens, children’s hobby groups, and other youth organizations around the world have made a point to celebrate Estonia's national language, whether on National Language Day or all year round.

  • foto
    Small islands get €640,000 to develop priority services
    08.03

    Starting today, funds can be applied for that will support projects to improve services for the inhabitants of Estonia’s small islands. The program includes 13 islands and total funds amounting to €640,000.

  • foto
    Eri Klas' funeral service
    03.03

    Composer and musician Eri Klas' funeral service took place in Estonia Concert Hall on Wednesday. Anyone who wanted to attend was welcome.