What Is the Value of Tartu Bus Validators?

A Tallinn bus validator, coming to Tartu buses as well? (Scott Abel/ERR)
Andrei Tuch
10/10/2014 3:59 PM
Category: Opinion

On September 24, the Tartu municipal government announced plans to switch the city’s bus network to a swipe card system similar to Tallinn’s onboard validators. There have been many reasons to criticize the capital’s free public transport scheme, and Andrei Tuch struggles to find any justification for what Tartu is planning.

The bus network in Tartu, Estonia’s second-biggest city, has been a source of love, hate, and disappointment for residents. A recent overhaul of the entire bus fleet, now in a uniform red-and-white-swirl livery, has been received very well. Technological advances like the construction of screens at most bus stops, showing the approaching buses and wait times, and the availability of that information through convenient mobile apps gifted to the city’s residents by a local IT company, Mobi Solutions, have made taking the bus a much more realistic proposition.

However, Tartu’s public transport is still suffering from patchy coverage - much of the city is a maze of small streets, and bus lines meander through them in sometimes odd loops. If you’re not lucky enough to live next to one of the city’s two big arteries, what would be a five-minute drive can take upwards of 40 minutes by infrequent public buses. In the past, it’s gotten so bad that two of the city’s large shopping centers have seen fit to start their own free shuttles, ferrying passengers from the center of town and back - and those lines are still popular, even after a new bus operator was brought in and the lines straightened.

Now the municipal government has introduced an ambitious new plan which they say will help improve coverage. From next autumn, Tartu will switch from the current ID-based ticketing system to an “e-ticket” - a scheme based on dedicated cards that must be waved past readers at the bus doors, just like Tallinn’s infamous “validators”. Tartu’s proposed scheme does have one advantage over the capital - it is not married to unique swipe cards. As described in the city’s press release, the system would work with any standard Near-Field Communication (NFC) token, which are included in most modern smartphones and can even come as stickers to randomly put on your wallet, bag, glove, etc. There's no need to surreptitiously disassemble green cards to re-weave them into wristbands.

However, in all other respects - and compared to Tartu’s existing system of bus ticketing - the new scheme will be a massive, constant inconvenience to residents. And to cause that inconvenience, the city is planning to spend at least 583,000 euros of taxpayer money.

The current system - which still exists quietly in Tallinn, although it’s not advertised - is based on the ID card infrastructure. You can buy tickets online, at kiosks, or via your mobile phone, and the only time you need to think about the ticket is if you are on a bus that gets randomly checked, in which case any document that shows your national ID number will serve to prove that you’ve paid for your trip.

The new system will require you to pre-load money into your account on the ticketing system, which will then be debited whenever you swipe or validate your token. Not only will this slow down boarding at peak times, but it leaves travelers at a risk of being caught short of funds. Today, I can call a phone number and have the cost of a ticket added to my phone bill at the end of the month, but with the new scheme I would have to … do what, exactly? Fumble about with my phone, trying to add money to my bus account? Inside a crowded morning bus? Or at a bus stop in the freezing winter?

The proposed system for Tartu manages the impressive feat of being strictly worse than the one in Tallinn. If the capital thinks that free public transport is worthwhile, it should just make it free for everybody, saving the cost of the validators, releasing the ticket checkers into more productive jobs, and attracting tourists and residents of surrounding towns to come and spend money in Tallinn.

But Tartu has no plans for free public transport for all residents. Schoolchildren and pensioners will ride for free, as they do now, and everyone else will still pay. And while Tallinn simply hides away the ID-based tickets in a dark corner, the Tartu city government has made it clear that ID tickets will go away entirely; only the token-based system will remain.

It is unclear whether visitors will still be able to purchase individual tickets from the bus driver. That's something that drivers universally and understandably hate, as it forces them to deal with cash transactions and slows down boarding at the same time. With the explanations given by the city in its press releases and responses to numerous angry Facebook comments, it actually looks as if on-board tickets will also go away.

This is not the first time that Tartu has tried to get strict about its bus traffic. More than a decade ago, there was a brief period of rigidly enforcing the rule of entering only through the front door, and showing proof of payment to the driver. This was universally hated, and did not work. Telling the driver “I bought a ticket on my phone” was enough to pass (technically, they were supposed to ask you to show them the SMS response on your phone, but there was no incentive for the drivers to make the boarding even slower). That bit of stupidity probably contributed to the disappearance of the Tarbus company from Tartu’s streets.

The new scheme is not being promoted by the current bus operator, AS Sebe (part of the group that runs most of Estonia’s intercity coaches). It was announced in a press release by the city government, and it is the city that is purchasing the token infrastructure and associated services from Ridango, the same company that’s behind Tallinn’s validators.

So, the new scheme is inconvenient, expensive, and redundant. The city says that it will result in a database of bus journeys, which can be used to improve bus coverage. But at best, this will tell city planners how many journeys begin at a given bus stop at a given time – not where those journeys end. Forcing people to swipe when they exit the bus is not realistic, especially in Tartu, where a large share of bus users are parents with baby carriages and older people with limited mobility. Statistics can be gathered in less disruptive ways, from cameras and weight sensors to mobile-phone monitooring systems – one such system is made by Regio, a Tartu-based IT company.

Is it worth paying over half a million euros out of the Tartu taxpayer’s pocket to buy a solution that is a strict downgrade from the existing system, but requires no effort or willingness to innovate on the part of the city government? Even when that solution is unlikely to provide useful data for future planning, but is very likely to slow down bus traffic and create an annoyance for every single bus rider in the city?

Tartu’s civilian-activist group Vabakund (which has a small representation on the city council) has reached out to the deputy mayor for explanations, but there has been no response at the time of writing this article.


The name field cannot be empty
No more than 50 characters
Comment field cannot be empty
No more than 50 characters
Comment field cannot be empty
No more than 1024 characters

Message forwarded to the editor

This Ip-address has limited access

There are no comments yet. Be the first!

Reply to comment

Reply to comment

Laadi juurde ({{take2}})
The name field cannot be empty
No more than 50 characters
Comment field cannot be empty
No more than 1024 characters
Add new comment
  • foto
    Opinion digest: Open Enterprise Estonia’s consultation services and assessments to competition

    Enterprise Estonia handed out advice to companies, and assessed whether or not they should receive public support, without being economically accountable, lawyer Taivo Ruus wrote in a Postimees opinion piece on Monday. This needed to change, and these activities delegated to professionals.

  • foto
    Opinion digest: The Reform Party’s new role

    After 17 years in government, Reform needed to find to a new role, and instead of being the manager of the Estonian state become a debater. How the party would get used to its new position, no longer able to dictate the political agenda, remained to be seen, said political scientist Mari-Liis Jakobson in a comment on Vikerraadio on Friday.

  • foto
    Andrus Karnau: Minister of Rural Affairs likely to be replaced

    Speaking on Sunday’s Raadio 2 broadcast of "State of the Union," radio show host Andrus Karnau found that the scandal to break out last week involving Martin Repinski’s goat farm was likely to culminate on Monday in his replacement as a minister of the newly-installed Estonian government.

  • foto
    Opinion digest: Baltic states on front line of new Cold War

    While the Baltic states would prefer full defensive capability, NATO is emphasizing its reinforcements’ function as a deterrent. The alliance would have to round off its military presence in the area with diplomacy, and political stability and dedication to liberal democratic values would play an important role maintaining the West’s solidarity, columnist Ahto Lobjakas wrote in an opinion piece published in daily Postimees.

  • foto
    Opinion digest: Putting Rail Baltica in its strategic context

    In an opinion piece in daily Postimees, former EU commissioner Siim Kallas points out that Rail Baltica goes far beyond considerations of its route on Estonian soil, and the money the government will have to invest. On the contrary, there is a broader European meaning that includes considering the strategic situation of Estonia.

  • foto
    Opinion digest: Dynasties and democracy don't go well together

    Speaking about the recent US presidential elections on Vikerraadio’s Sunday broadcast of "Samost and Rumm," hosts Anvar Samost and Hannes Rumm recognized that Donald Trump’s election win is being considered as the destruction of two political dynasties there, however democracy and dynasties don’t go well together anyway.

  • foto
    Opinion: Estonia’s lasting isolation

    The fact that too many foreign journalists do not understand the Estonian language, and that they have no access to the local political culture and its players, has distorted reports abroad of what happened this week, writes ERR News editor Dario Cavegn.

  • foto
    Alo Lõhmus: Left turns and ‘silent submission’

    The embarrassing conflation of the Reform Party’s self-image with the Estonian state is proof that it is high time they are sent into opposition, says journalist Alo Lõhmus.

  • foto
    Opinion: Getting rid of ruling party's privileges doesn't damage Estonia's reputation

    On Friday, the ministers of the Social Democrats (SDE) and the Pro Patra and Res Publica Union (IRL) began calling back Reform Party members from the boards of state-owned companies and funds. The Reform Party’s reaction was an announcement published on Sunday — a rather strange one, finds ERR News editor Dario Cavegn.

  • foto
    Opinion digest: Ärma is more than just numbers

    Ärma Farm’s funding scandal was overshadowing the achievements of Toomas Hendrik Ilves’ presidency, including the fact that Estonia had benefited from state visits that Ilves hosted in Ärma, Prime Minister Taavi Rõivas (Reform) said to ERR on Thursday.

  • foto
    Benno Schirrmeister: Do Estonians dream of electric sheep?

    On a journalist exchange in Estonia, Benno Schirrmeister of Bremen’s TAZ is highly informed, yet a blank slate as far as a foreigner’s experience of Estonia is concerned. In his first op-ed about Tallinn, he spots something beyond IT that Estonia could advertise — but doesn’t.

  • foto
    Erkki Bahovski: Was 1940 approach better than modern journalism's 'war hysteria'?

    Linguist Urmas Sutrop has claimed that Estonian journalism is scaring people with the specter of war. Editor-in-Chief of monthly magazine Diplomaatia Erkki Bahovski, however, doesn’t agree.

  • foto
    Opinion digest: Kremlin in danger of losing sense of reality

    According to Ingo Mannteufel, head of the Department for Russia and Europe at Deutsche Welle, there is a possibility of the Kremlin starting to believe its own propaganda, which could lead to dangerous decisions both domestically and internationally.

  • foto
    Opinion digest: Estonia’s stagnating politics

    Estonia’s largest political parties had been going through the most serious crisis in their existence, and on top of that they had lost their most important function, namely to formulate a vision of the country’s future, daily Postimees wrote in its Friday editorial.

  • foto
    Opinion digest: Putin exploiting power vacuum created by U.S. presidential elections

    According to director of Tallinn’s International Centre for Defence and Security and former ambassador to Russia, Jüri Luik, the increased tensions over the past few weeks between Russia and the West indicate Putin’s wish to exploit the ambiguous mood before the U.S. presidential elections as much as possible.

  • foto
    Opinion digest: Time to return to discussing serious issues

    In a stinging opinion piece in published in the daily Eesti Päevaleht, member of the Riigikogu Eerik-Niiles Kross (Reform) condemned the Estonian media as well as the country’s elites for their obsession with what he sees as pointless topics, while disregarding the last few weeks’ unsettling developments concerning Russia.

  • foto
    Opinion digest: Legally speaking, everything is proper

    After Toomas Hendrik Ilves’ decade in office, and after he promoted Estonia like no other president did before him, his legacy is now tainted by the fact that he seems to have gone for a substantial state grant in 2006 that he never put to use — and of which he will now pay back just a tenth.

  • foto
    Opinion digest: Closer to Warsaw, farther away from Estonia

    In a recent opinion piece in daily Postimees, columnist Ahto Lobjakas wrote that one way to look at Rail Baltic was as a step towards the level other countries had already reached in terms of speed and comfort of their railway connections. The main weakness of this point of view was the fact that in Estonia, it lacked the necessary social context.

  • foto
    Opinion digest: Leadership change in Reform needed for potential coalition with Center Party

    For a potential future coalition with the Center Party, the Reform Party needed to change its leader as well, Social Democratic MP and chairman of the Riigikogu’s Foreign Affairs Committee Sven Mikser wrote in a comment on social media on Friday.

  • foto
    Matthew Crandall: President Ilves’ global impact

    The greatest accomplishment of President Toomas Hendrik Ilves is that he branded Estonia as a modern and innovative 21st century country, and brought it out of post-Soviet obscurity, writes Tallinn University’s Matthew Crandall.

  • foto
    The shackles of history and modern life in the fast lane: Estonia's experience in the migration crisis

    The uncertain public performances of Estonian politicians and poor explanatory work were to blame for a considerable increase in public distrust during the migration crisis, found ERR journalist Greete Palmiste, working in Bremen on an international journalists' exchange, in an opinion piece written for German publication taz.die Tageszeitung.

  • foto
    Opinion digest: Kersti Kaljulaid on the concepts of ethical nationalism and confident Estonians

    On Friday, Aug. 12, Estonian representative to the European Court of Auditors Kersti Kaljulaid delivered a patriotic speech on the Postimees Stage at the 2016 Opinion Festival in Paide in which she expanded on two words and two respective ideas she found important for her country that were represented by the two letter Es in its native-language name Eesti: eetiline (ethical) and enesekindel (confident).

  • foto
    This mess we're in: Picking up the pieces after Saturday's elections

    From Saturday’s election fiasco to Tuesday’s sudden emergence of a likely cross-party candidate: ERR News editor Dario Cavegn makes an attempt at explaining Estonia’s seemingly chaotic quest to find its next president.

  • foto
    Opinion: The decline of Estonian as a language of science starts abroad

    The Estonian language as a language of science is only sustainable in those subject areas that offer undergraduate courses in Estonian, and with which students begin their university education, finds ERR science portal editor Marju Himma.

  • foto
    Opinion digest: Current approach to reform won't help municipalities

    The Center Party’s presidential candidate, Mailis Reps, wrote in an opinion piece published in daily Postimees on Sunday that the Administrative Reform Act was a disappointment to Estonia’s municipalities, and that relations between local and central government were in a crisis.

  • foto
    Opinion: Jüri Nikolajev in response to the Ida-Viru secret memo

    Describing himself as "wearily spiteful" instead of angry, ERR's Narva correspondent Jüri Nikolajev responded to the top secret memo on Ida-Viru County that leaked recently, calling Estonians to figuratively not leave their property laying around if they did not want anyone else to take it for themselves.

  • foto
    Opinion digest: Sulev Vedler on the secret memo on Ida-Viru County

    In 2015, the Government Security Committee received a secret memo containing a dark assessment of the future of Ida-Viru County, Estonia's most northeastern and predominantly Russian-speaking county, which was compiled by Ilmar Raag, who worked as a strategic communicatins advisor at the Stenbock House at the time. Estonian journalist Sulev Vedler responded to the memo by compiling various reactions to issues it addressed.

  • foto
    Opinion: Alo Lõhmus on the definition of Estonian citizen by blood

    Journalist Alo Lõhmus explored the right to Estonian citizenship by "jus sanguinis," Latin for right of blood, as it relates to one's eligibility to run for president — an issue which has had particular attention drawn to it recently after members of a competing political party attempted to cast doubt on the status of presidential candidate Marina Kaljurand's Estonian citizenship.

  • foto
    Opinion digest: Erkki Bahovski on Finland and the alleged Baltic scheming

    Columnist Erkki Bahovski commented on the curious, decidedly defensive turn that seemed to be taken by Finland's Social Democrats following the release of a lengthy report by the Finnish Institute of International Affairs (UPI) which suggested that Russia, in its own self-interest, is attempting to hamper Finland's total integration with the West.

  • foto
    Opinion digest: Siim Kallas thinks real estate tax effective way to finance local government

    The Reform Party’s presidential candidate, Siim Kallas, said in an opinion piece published in daily Postimees that an estate tax, more precisely a tax levied on real estate, could be considered to finance local government.