FATCA sows discrimination, unconstitutionality in banking (11)

(US National Archives and Records Administration)
Päivi Pilvepiir
1/20/2015 10:16 AM
Category: Opinion

The Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act, the attempt by the US government to reel in money from its citizens living abroad (including people who may not know they are citizens) has been in the news for at least five years. Now, some six months after implementation, banks are getting serious about enforcement, causing tempers to rise and, in some cases, violating the Estonian Constitution.

FATCA was set up, like all roads to hot offshore places, with good intentions - to wipe out tax avoidance/evasion and presumably to bring a little bit more money into the recessionary, pre-oil-glut US economy of 2008-9. But it's not just tax evaders on tropical islands who are feeling the pinch, but ordinary Americans in this shipshape and above-board Nordic country as well.

Even people who have been in the country since the early 1990s are suddenly getting the cold shoulder and a definite persona-non-grata vibe when they go into banks where they have been doing business, sometimes for years.

But this piece is not just a rant about the long arm of Estonia's powerful protector. Estonian citizens are affected, too, and it's here that some of Estonia's biggest banks have begun acting in an unconstitutional manner.

What has long been considered one of the biggest blessings - American by birth - has in this one case become an onerous burden. At most of Estonia's banks, tellers have been instructed to check customer files for any sign of a connection to the US, such as place of birth. If a customer is flagged, then without preamble or explanation, the teller initiates a series of questions, such as "what is your taxpayer number" - by which they mean the US social security number.

I faced it, too, when I opened an account in August. I had no problem with it. I don't live in Estonia year-round, spending equal time in Marin County, and I do know my "taxpayer number" and surrendered the data, though the whole thing felt surreal.

But there are quite a few folks with no actual connection with the US besides a place of birth. If they want to avoid the wrangle, the burden is on them to sort it all out. That is wrong.

I do understand the banks' view. Because of the intergovernmental agreement between Estonia and the US, they're in panic mode, because they know that eventually there may be a bad apple among the Americans, and if they don't weed them out, they or their parent company could face major penalties on any institutional business they do with America.

But their response has been overweening and discriminatory. Essentially banks have assumed the role of being interpreters of US citizenship law, assuming that a place of birth is equal to citizenship or tax home in the US.

It's ineffective as well, as the tactic would not detect US persons who were born in other places besides the US.

An acquaintance of mine who has a "dirty" Estonian ID card (place of birth: Ameerika Ühendriigid) relates her recent visit to a branch outside Tallinn. In effect, she could not complete the procedure she came to the bank for. Ten minutes became 15, but the teller kept on pressing her for a mysterious taxpayer number. "Has my account been frozen?" my acquaintance finally asked.

The answer was no: at least not yet. But there was a teller service charge for the procedure, and because the bank didn't have the customer's (American) taxpayer number, the teller said the bank could not deduct the €2 for the procedure.

This only hardened the customer's resolve not to cooperate in any way (in fact, the customer had no knowledge of whether she had ever been issued a taxpayer number by the US, a foreign country to her, and could not have cooperated). It later turned out to be a bluff by the teller: the transaction was completed but the customer was let off with a warning that "soon things will get even more difficult" and a demand for a "letter from the embassy."

Oof. It's always painful when organizations controlling money that belongs to you start acting shabbily. But besides setting a poor customer service standard and sowing bad blood, the banks' actions may even be unconstitutional.

Article 12 of the Constitution states, in part: "No one shall be discriminated against on the basis of nationality, race, colour, sex, language [or] origin."

Late last year, Estonia had a news event where one politician (the son of a man born in Estonia) singled out another politician (the son of a person not born in Estonia) based on origin. The first politician, Finance Minister Jürgen Ligi, paid with his job. The outcry was swift and he was forced to resign.

There is no such thing as different grades of Estonian citizen based on where they were born - whether they were born in Russia and naturalized or born in Germany on the way to the US or born in the US somewhere along the long road to freedom and back. (There's only one distinction made: those who have citizenship by birth cannot be stripped of it.)

An Estonian citizen who is not conducting business with the US, who lives in Estonia, pays all taxes there, and is not aware of a connection with the US, should not be required by an Estonian bank to research and supply data from a foreign government at the citizen's expense. Period. To argue otherwise is perverse. If the US wants to track down such persons, and use extraordinary rendition on them, or whatever the terminology nowadays is, that is their prerogative. If the bank wants to track down the data, that is their right.

I know: Estonian Americans are not in an underdog position (Russians have more cause for at least perceived defensiveness or uncertainty), but this is not meant as an exploitation complaint but as a pure intellectual argument: no sort of discrimination should be tolerated. An Estonian citizen is an Estonian citizen.

The fact that the banking sector, being a vital service, is so closely entwined with the public sector (banks issue ID card codes and are a major authentication channel for everything short of an actual digital signature) makes it even more imperative that banks act in a proper, non-discriminatory manner. Insofar as they are vital service providers, they are extensions of the state, and they should not hassle people based on where they were born. It's a different matter if there's clear actvity on the bank statement that signals a liabillity.

The new chancellor of justice will certainly be hearing about this one.

Päivi Pilvepiir files her tax returns properly each year in both countries, one as Päivi and the other as Paivi.

The name field cannot be empty
No more than 50 characters
Comment field cannot be empty
No more than 50 characters
Comment field cannot be empty
No more than 1024 characters

Message forwarded to the editor

This Ip-address has limited access

See also

There are no comments yet. Be the first!

Reply to comment

Reply to comment

Laadi juurde ({{take2}})
The name field cannot be empty
No more than 50 characters
Comment field cannot be empty
No more than 1024 characters
Add new comment
  • foto
    Opinion digest: Estonia’s stagnating politics

    Estonia’s largest political parties had been going through the most serious crisis in their existence, and on top of that they had lost their most important function, namely to formulate a vision of the country’s future, daily Postimees wrote in its Friday editorial.

  • foto
    Opinion digest: Putin exploiting power vacuum created by U.S. presidential elections

    According to director of Tallinn’s International Centre for Defence and Security and former ambassador to Russia, Jüri Luik, the increased tensions over the past few weeks between Russia and the West indicate Putin’s wish to exploit the ambiguous mood before the U.S. presidential elections as much as possible.

  • foto
    Opinion digest: Time to return to discussing serious issues

    In a stinging opinion piece in published in the daily Eesti Päevaleht, member of the Riigikogu Eerik-Niiles Kross (Reform) condemned the Estonian media as well as the country’s elites for their obsession with what he sees as pointless topics, while disregarding the last few weeks’ unsettling developments concerning Russia.

  • foto
    Opinion digest: Legally speaking, everything is proper

    After Toomas Hendrik Ilves’ decade in office, and after he promoted Estonia like no other president did before him, his legacy is now tainted by the fact that he seems to have gone for a substantial state grant in 2006 that he never put to use — and of which he will now pay back just a tenth.

  • foto
    Opinion digest: Closer to Warsaw, farther away from Estonia

    In a recent opinion piece in daily Postimees, columnist Ahto Lobjakas wrote that one way to look at Rail Baltic was as a step towards the level other countries had already reached in terms of speed and comfort of their railway connections. The main weakness of this point of view was the fact that in Estonia, it lacked the necessary social context.

  • foto
    Opinion digest: Leadership change in Reform needed for potential coalition with Center Party

    For a potential future coalition with the Center Party, the Reform Party needed to change its leader as well, Social Democratic MP and chairman of the Riigikogu’s Foreign Affairs Committee Sven Mikser wrote in a comment on social media on Friday.

  • foto
    Matthew Crandall: President Ilves’ global impact

    The greatest accomplishment of President Toomas Hendrik Ilves is that he branded Estonia as a modern and innovative 21st century country, and brought it out of post-Soviet obscurity, writes Tallinn University’s Matthew Crandall.

  • foto
    The shackles of history and modern life in the fast lane: Estonia's experience in the migration crisis

    The uncertain public performances of Estonian politicians and poor explanatory work were to blame for a considerable increase in public distrust during the migration crisis, found ERR journalist Greete Palmiste, working in Bremen on an international journalists' exchange, in an opinion piece written for German publication taz.die Tageszeitung.

  • foto
    Opinion digest: Kersti Kaljulaid on the concepts of ethical nationalism and confident Estonians

    On Friday, Aug. 12, Estonian representative to the European Court of Auditors Kersti Kaljulaid delivered a patriotic speech on the Postimees Stage at the 2016 Opinion Festival in Paide in which she expanded on two words and two respective ideas she found important for her country that were represented by the two letter Es in its native-language name Eesti: eetiline (ethical) and enesekindel (confident).

  • foto
    This mess we're in: Picking up the pieces after Saturday's elections

    From Saturday’s election fiasco to Tuesday’s sudden emergence of a likely cross-party candidate: ERR News editor Dario Cavegn makes an attempt at explaining Estonia’s seemingly chaotic quest to find its next president.

  • foto
    Opinion: The decline of Estonian as a language of science starts abroad

    The Estonian language as a language of science is only sustainable in those subject areas that offer undergraduate courses in Estonian, and with which students begin their university education, finds ERR science portal editor Marju Himma.

  • foto
    Opinion digest: Current approach to reform won't help municipalities

    The Center Party’s presidential candidate, Mailis Reps, wrote in an opinion piece published in daily Postimees on Sunday that the Administrative Reform Act was a disappointment to Estonia’s municipalities, and that relations between local and central government were in a crisis.

  • foto
    Opinion: Jüri Nikolajev in response to the Ida-Viru secret memo

    Describing himself as "wearily spiteful" instead of angry, ERR's Narva correspondent Jüri Nikolajev responded to the top secret memo on Ida-Viru County that leaked recently, calling Estonians to figuratively not leave their property laying around if they did not want anyone else to take it for themselves.

  • foto
    Opinion digest: Sulev Vedler on the secret memo on Ida-Viru County

    In 2015, the Government Security Committee received a secret memo containing a dark assessment of the future of Ida-Viru County, Estonia's most northeastern and predominantly Russian-speaking county, which was compiled by Ilmar Raag, who worked as a strategic communicatins advisor at the Stenbock House at the time. Estonian journalist Sulev Vedler responded to the memo by compiling various reactions to issues it addressed.

  • foto
    Opinion: Alo Lõhmus on the definition of Estonian citizen by blood

    Journalist Alo Lõhmus explored the right to Estonian citizenship by "jus sanguinis," Latin for right of blood, as it relates to one's eligibility to run for president — an issue which has had particular attention drawn to it recently after members of a competing political party attempted to cast doubt on the status of presidential candidate Marina Kaljurand's Estonian citizenship.

  • foto
    Opinion digest: Erkki Bahovski on Finland and the alleged Baltic scheming

    Columnist Erkki Bahovski commented on the curious, decidedly defensive turn that seemed to be taken by Finland's Social Democrats following the release of a lengthy report by the Finnish Institute of International Affairs (UPI) which suggested that Russia, in its own self-interest, is attempting to hamper Finland's total integration with the West.

  • foto
    Opinion digest: Siim Kallas thinks real estate tax effective way to finance local government

    The Reform Party’s presidential candidate, Siim Kallas, said in an opinion piece published in daily Postimees that an estate tax, more precisely a tax levied on real estate, could be considered to finance local government.

  • foto
    Opinion digest: Siret Kotka on the support, or lack thereof, for Estonia's farmers

    Vice-Chairman of the Riigikogu’s Rural Affairs Committee MP Siret Kotka (Center) found that while Estonia's farmers have recently suffered one blow after another, the current Estonian government owes them more support than they have been paid, and likewise found that it is precisely domestically grown food that should make up the backbone of Estonian security.

  • foto
    Dario Cavegn: The intellectual crisis and editors’ internal conflict

    Iivi Anna Masso’s piece published on Sept. 6 is unfit for publication. ERR News editor Dario Cavegn explains this verdict, and why it ended up getting published anyway.

  • foto
    Iivi Anna Masso: The migration crisis and liberals' internal conflict

    Columnist Iivi Anna Masso asks why people with a liberal world view couldn't support freedom of movement for work, studies, marriage, and genuine political asylum while at the same time support more effective protection of European cultural values.

  • foto
    Opinion digest: Hanneli Rudi makes case for starting school a year younger

    Prompted by the arrival of September 1, the first day of school for children across Estonia, Hanneli Rudi reflected on how kindergarten is simply a good way for schools to make money in light of the fact that it has been deemed unnecessary for most children's development, and that perhaps the country should instead consider having children start first grade one year younger, at age six.

  • foto
    Opinion digest: Mikk Salu on the open secret of Estonia’s emergency underpreparedness

    Journalist Mikk Salu recently addressed an issue about which it seems like many in the country are whispering but no one will come out and say — that despite appearances to the contrary, Estonia's military, law enforcement agencies, hospitals and other such critical support agencies are woefully understaffed, underequipped and underprepared for the event of a true emergency.

  • foto
    Dario Cavegn: Kaljurand, the reluctant candidate

    Over the past months, there have been several occasions when the Estonian media assumed that Marina Kaljurand, much like everybody else in the country’s government and legislature, was working on some political scheme, aiming to move up in the long term. This is nonsense, writes Dario Cavegn.

  • foto
    Letter from a reader: In favor of paper ballots in e-Estonia

    Reader Virgo Kruve submitted a letter to ERR on Monday evening, following the first round of presidential elections in the Riigikogu, defending the continued use of seemingly relatively antiquated paper ballots in the presidential elections of a country famous precisely for its well-established use of electronic voting in local and parliamentary elections.

  • foto
    Opinion digest: Evelyn Sepp on the election cycle and the importance of the president

    Just days before the Estonia’s 2016 presidential elections, which kicked off with the first round of balloting in the Riigikogu on Monday, former politician and MP Evelyn Sepp reflected on how positively this year’s presidential campaign has been handled and why exactly Estonia needs a president in the first place, expounding upon the respective roles of the Riigikogu, the government and the president for context as well.

  • foto
    Opinion digest: Two takes on Angela Merkel’s political personality

    Just in time for Merkel’s visit on Wednesday and Thursday this week, two takes on her character and political convictions have appeared in the Estonian press. In Päevaleht, director Katrin Laur writes about a politically bland, but nevertheless successful woman, and in Ekspress, journalist Külli-Riin Tigasson lists six ethics rules that Merkel has followed.

  • foto
    Marko Mihkelson: A common Europe’s struggle for existence

    Despite both recent and ongoing events which have served to cast doubt in many Europeans on the future of the EU, Estonian MP Marko Mihkelson found that Europe is nonetheless stronger when it stands together, and that in the face of external threats that it cannot prevent, the union must continue to build stronger ties upon the shared desire for peace and stability which serves as its foundation.

  • foto
    Center Party could raise its profile explaining NATO to local Russians

    While 88% of Estonians support increasing NATO’s military presence, most local Russians are against it. That’s 25% of the country’s population. The Center Party could explain to them what caused the increased allied presence, reduce opposition to Estonia’s defense policy, and gain a lot in the process, Erik Gamzejev writes.

  • foto
    Uber is in Estonia for Taxify

    Uber is in Estonia for two reasons: For PR, and to kill Taxify. But the price war it has kicked off just in time for the weekend rush isn't how they're hoping to get the Estonian start-up. It's part of Uber's typical strategy in every market it enters. It will blow over, eventually resulting in higher prices.

  • foto
    Why is anyone surprised? Look to the unilateral decisions of Obama and Merkel for the passage of Brexit

    University of Tartu guest history lecturer Joseph Enge thinks that the UK's vote to leave the European Union is both reasonable and rational, and that it should not come as a surprise. Even more, the current criticism of the voters shows that they are right to leave.