Music for the Masses: ERR News Editors Share Their Thoughts on Eesti Laul (1)

2/14/2014 4:30 PM
Category: Opinion

The first half of the first round of the Estonian Song Contest, Eesti Laul, the prelude to Eurovision, will air tonight at 21.45 on ETV. As Eurovision is a welcome chance to leave good taste, manners and professionalism at home, ERR News's staff has taken the liberty to offer its own thoughts on tonight's contenders.

The first number after the comments (on a 10-point scale) are how much the editor liked the song in question. The second number is a estimate of the song's suitability for the Eurovision contest, a Eurovision-Suitability-Score (ESS), if it were to advance.

What are your picks for tonight?

1. Amazing – Tanja

SA: Not terrible, but not memorable. Five minutes later, I can't remember what it sounded like, other than a woman sang it. (5, 4)

KK: Standard computer-generated Eurodisco fare, not doing any favours to Tanja’s voice. Ctrl+Alt+Delete, moving on. (3, 8)

JML: Steering-wheel drumming traffic-jam music at best. Add pyrotechnics and short skirts and it could pass the Eurovision semifinals. (5, 8)

2. Flame – The Titles

SA: If this was the Oscars, it wouldn't win Best Picture, but something like a technical award for Best Use of a Synthesizer. (6, 4)

KK: A few hooks shy of a catchy unpretentious electro-pop song. Like the vocals, but ultimately a snooze. (6, 5)  

JML: If it wins I can see many hipsters using it as a ring tone. Do people still do that? (6, 3)

3. Resignal – Wilhelm

SA: This band has a lead singer with a compelling voice, a nice ballad, and a group of members who appear to have a modicum of musical talent. This song doesn't have a prayer. (7, 5)

KK: The extra points they gain for music they lose for the lyrics. “Resignal is being so hard”. Really? I know this is Eurovision, but still - really? (5, 6)

JML: Another example of typical Estonian music – talented musicians, awful song writing. (4, 2)

 4. Solina – State of Zoe

SA: Was this song on the Shaft movie soundtrack? (6, 7)

KK: As far as production quality and personal tastes go, it’s the best of the bunch. (8, 7)

JML: The Chorus merits a mention, but the song is too unemotional for Eurovision. (4,3)

 5. Sandra – NimmerSchmidt

SA: This, quite possibily, is the musical fruit of years of being beat up for your lunch money in high school. (4, 4)

KK: Like a puppy trying to lick my ears. No, for the love of God, no. (4, 8)

JML: I really hope there is a person called Sandra, and she appreciates these kinds of songs. Otherwise it's a wasted effort. (2, 2)

 6. Maailm on hull – VÖÖRAD

SA: Now, if the lead singer was wearing the Darth Vader helmet, you would have Eesti Laul gold. Instead, we get the whitest Ice-T wannabe performance of the new millennium. In the video, the female chorus woman seems to be bolted to the floor. Let's see if she regains some mobility tonight. (5, 4)

KK: Take one tablespoons of early 1990s house, a sprinkle of dubstep, mix it with faux-naive lyrics, add flat female vocals, let it simmer for five minutes, throw in the trash bin. (4, 7)

JML: VÖÖRAD has many similarities with Estonian athletes in Sochi: they try, but not very hard, no high expectations, suspicion of drug use. (3,7)

 7. Maybe-Maybe – Super Hot Cosmos Blues Band

SA: What is it with all the sci-fi shoutouts in this year's acts? First, we have Darth Vader. Maybe-Maybe gets the Coneheads to join them. Otherwise, a decent Neil Young cover band. (6, 6)

KK: Echoes of "I Feel You" by Depeche Mode descend into a grating chorus. Not bad. (7, 7)

JML: Extremely suitable to play in the backdrop of a bar fight in a western-type saloon, but it's a 'no' for Eurovision. (4,3)

 8. Kus on EXIT? – August Hunt

SA: I'm certain the lead singer will have a certain cachet among a particular segment of the Eesti Laul demographic. But as for the music, August Hunt might as well be named "Hell Hunt", as in "Gentle Wolf". A safe tune, without any risks or standout elements. I do wish I had his hair. (6, 6)

KK: Hello, Hall. Hello, Oates, meet your bastard grandsons. (4, 6)

JML: The good news for August Hunt is that half of the Balkan nations have pulled out of this year's competition. So there will only be 5-10 songs exactly the same. (3, 9)

 9. Tule ja jää – Kõrsikud

SA: A nice tune, with a certain "just crawled out from behind the Jaanipäev bonfire" style. This is so anti-Eurovision, it might actually find some legs in the largest contest. But can it find one in Eesti Laul voting? (8, 8)

KK: Like with Jaan Pehk’s Valss, we may have another runaway hit among the four-to-five-year-old demographic on our hands. Chances of winning depend on the generosity of parents across the country. (5, 5)

JML: A nostalgia song that breaks out when a group of friends reminisce the good old times, while sitting around a fireplace drinking beer. Not as catchy as their previous Euro-attempts, but should make it to the final round of Eesti Laul. (7, 3)

10. Supernoova – Lenna

SA: Lenna's a known quanity in Eesti Laul and Eurovision contests. From those in the know, this wasn't the strongest track on her latest album. But maybe being Eesti Laul royalty will give a boost in the polling. (7, 6)

KK: She always seems to be singing just one song and not a particularly memorable one at that. Still, I guess that’s her thing and third time lucky, perhaps? (5, 6)

JML: Can't put on a Eesti Laul contest without the nation's sweetheart. The strongest song of the first semi-final, and I love the word “purpur” (crimson) from 0:59 on the track. (9, 5)

 

Final Predictions

SA (Scott Abel): I like Kõrsikud, Lenna, and State of Zoe to be in the mix with the voters, while I'm holding out hope for Wilhelm. As for what the judges think, who the heck knows (Winny Puhh and Laura finishing second in their respective years because of the judge's input were travesties). And with most Eesti Laul contests, whomever wins in the end, we will all probably lose.

KK (Kaisa Kaer): At the risk of sounding astoundingly original, I think I will go and listen to some Winny Puhh now. 

JML (Juhan-Markus Laats): Hoping for a stronger second semi-final. Only Lenna merits a mention as a contender, but as last year, her song is completely useless at a Eurovision final. Kõrsikud will go through, as well as August Hunt (the hair, as Scott pointed out), State of Zoe (for quality) and Tanja (a ton of radio-play).


The name field cannot be empty
No more than 50 characters
Comment field cannot be empty
No more than 50 characters
Comment field cannot be empty
No more than 1024 characters
{{error}}

Message forwarded to the editor

This Ip-address has limited access

See also

There are no comments yet. Be the first!

Reply to comment

+{{childComment.ReplyToName}}:
Reply to comment
Reply

Laadi juurde ({{take2}})
The name field cannot be empty
No more than 50 characters
Comment field cannot be empty
No more than 1024 characters
{{error}}
Add new comment
  • foto
    Contest: Pick the Winner of Eesti Laul
    2014

    The Eesti Laul competition climaxes on Saturday, naming Estonia's representative to the Eurovision contest in May in Copenhagen. Ten finalists have been chosen in the last two weeks, and now ERR News would like to know who you think will win, and give you a little modest prize for your correct prognostication to boot.

  • foto
    Eesti Laul II: The Wrath of Song
    2014

    We are halfway through the first round of Eesti Laul, the gateway to the country's representative to the Eurovision song contest in Copenhagen in May. ERR News editors have weighed in with their take on tonight's ten, but don't be scared off by the Olympic-scale negativity, tune in yourself at 21:45 to ETV tonight.

  • foto
    Music for the Masses: ERR News Editors Share Their Thoughts on Eesti Laul
    2014

    The first half of the first round of the Estonian Song Contest, Eesti Laul, the prelude to Eurovision, will air tonight at 21.45 on ETV. As Eurovision is a welcome chance to leave good taste, manners and professionalism at home, ERR News's staff has taken the liberty to offer its own thoughts on tonight's contenders.

  • foto
  • foto
    ERR News 2.0 Goes Live
    2013

    ERR News is proud to open its new-look website today, reflecting a unified visual identity for the entire Estonian public broadcasting corporation.