Finnish PEN club: Kender’s ‘U12’ is a ‘grotesque thriller’, not child porn (5)

Kaur Kender (right) and his lawyer, Paul Keres (Siim Lõvi /ERR)
7/17/2016 8:39 AM
Category: Culture

“It is the work of the writer to investigate what it means to be human. The writer has to examine areas that can be social and moral taboos. Particularly in today’s world, where these taboos are a center point and commercial subject of the entertainment industry, including death, serial murder, pornography, and pedophilia,” the Finnish PEN club writes in its position on the Kaur Kender case.

Kender published a short story in 2014 that features what has been referred to as “graphic descriptions” of sexual violence against children. The story, called “Untitled-12”, was banned, the Internal Security Service began an investigation of Kender, and the writer was subsequently charged with the creation and distribution of child pornography.

His case has been the subject of plenty of debate around the question whether a story like “Untitled-12” can be seen as child pornography at all, and if its writer can be held criminally responsible for its production and distribution. Kender had made his work available online.

While Kender’s case has had a lot of attention, the subject matter of sexual morals in literature is hardly new. Dating back to the time of the ancient Greeks and Romans, erotic poetry and fiction has always been part of Western literary history. The vast majority of erotic excursions in present-day writing seem outright tame when compared to some of these works.

Writers whose work was seen as pornographic at the time it was first published include James Joyce, Norman Mailer, D. H. Lawrence, Henry Miller, Jean Genet, and many others. There is a whole line of books that are still considered at least scandalous, including “Lolita” by Vladimir Nabokov, the works of the Marquis de Sade, and so on.

With child abuse, Kender chose a subject for his story that remains extremely complicated. As the Finnish PEN club writes in its statement, the awareness of the problem today and the measures taken against it are in stark contrast to the fact that anonymous porn, no matter the medium used in its creation, is spreading, making the literary dissection of perversions inevitable as well as uncomfortable.

As they point out, dealing with matters like war and genocide in literature often covers subjects that could easily be seen as immoral or even perverse, but they are hardly ever scrutinized. And where they are, fame and recognition can go hand in hand with judgement and damnation, as in the case of Jonathan Littell’s work “The Kindly Ones”, which got him the reputation of a racist and pervert as well as a Prix Goncourt, France’s most prestigious literary award.

“Kender’s story ‘Untitled-12’ is a grotesque thriller about the psychological decay of a sexual maniac and serial killer. It becomes a pornographic parody where it quotes bible verses and takes exaggeration to the absurd and borrows its ending from the Marquis de Sade’s ‘120 Days of Sodom’,” the statement of the Finnish PEN reads. They go on to compare the thinking patterns of the main character to the work of American writer Philip Roth (“Portnoy’s Complaint”).

“Kender doesn’t use an all-knowing narrator’s voice to relieve the reader, but takes them directly into the mind of the main protagonist. The strategy of such storytelling is a feature of his books. Throwing everything aside that could serve as a framework for his unpleasant topic, he only shows the true content of otherwise accepted works in culture and entertainment.”

As Kender himself once put it in an interview, his stories are what one gets removing everything from a novel like Bret Easton Ellis’ “American Psycho” except the violence it portrays. To see the subject of such literary reduction in “Untitled-12” as child pornography is absurd, the Finnish PEN states.

On the contrary, the story would be a good fit for the University of Helsinki’s “Literature and Evil” lecture series, the Finnish PEN club finds, the description of which it quotes as follows:

“In the lectures we familiarize with the way evil is expressed in European literature in particular, and discuss the philosophical and sociological examination of evil. In particular, we examine in depth the famous characters of literary history through which evil is expressed, the depiction of human and supernatural evil in literature, the representation of violence, shock and transgression in literature, but also discuss the danger of literature, how ‘bad’ writing can be abnormal and bring with it bad consequences.”

The Kender case continues, with the latest development being the judge’s order of a psychiatric evaluation of the writer.

Would you like to contribute to ERR News? Send your article or opinion piece to news@err.ee. If you can think of a topic you’d like to see covered, or if you have any other feedback, let us know.

Editor: Dario Cavegn

The name field cannot be empty
No more than 50 characters
Comment field cannot be empty
No more than 50 characters
Comment field cannot be empty
No more than 1024 characters
{{error}}

Message forwarded to the editor

This Ip-address has limited access

See also

There are no comments yet. Be the first!

Reply to comment

+{{childComment.ReplyToName}}:
Reply to comment
Reply

Laadi juurde ({{take2}})
The name field cannot be empty
No more than 50 characters
Comment field cannot be empty
No more than 1024 characters
{{error}}
Add new comment
  • foto
    Kihnu dictionary to be presented at book release in Pärnu
    17.01

    A new dictionary of the Kihnu dialect of Estonian, compiled by island natives Reene Leas, Silvi Murulauk and Reti Könninge as well as the late Saaremaa native linguist Ellen Niit, will be presented at a book release at the Museum of New Art in Pärnu on Saturday, Jan. 21 at 12 p.m.

  • foto
    Culture.ee's weekly recommendations: Jan. 16-22
    16.01

    Weekly recommendations for cultural events taking place in Estonia this week as curated by and published in the Culture critics’ blog at culture.ee: "We have a feeling it’s going to be a very eventful and interesting week!"

  • foto
    Rakvere theater sees 100,000 visitors in 2016
    16.01

    2016 brought with it a number of changes for Rakvere Theatre — including the opening of its long-awaited new movie and rehearsal hall, designed by Raul Vaiksoo, in the fall, the international theater festival Baltoscandal as well as the large-scale summer production of "At the End of the World" — which helped the theater log over 100,000 visits during the year.

  • foto
    Two Estonian films to be screened at Scandinavian Film Festival in Los Angeles
    15.01

    The Scandinavian Film Festival that began in Los Angeles on Saturday will feature two films by Estonian movie-makers.

  • foto
    Copyrights to works of Estonian poets Under, Adson in German hands
    11.01

    The Estonian Ministry of Culture has discovered that the copyrights to the works of Estonian poets Marie Under and Artur Adson do not belong to the Estonian state.

  • foto
    Estonian clown duo Piip ja Tuut put on record number of performances abroad
    10.01

    Of their 264 performances in 2016, Piip ja Tuut put on 118 at their own Piip ja Tuut Playhouse, located on Tallinn’s Toompea Hill, and 146 elsewhere, including 30 performances in a total of eight countries around the world.

  • foto
    Museums, theaters increase ticket prices
    10.01

    The beginning of the new year brought with it increases in ticket prices in some cultural institutions. Prices were adjusted mostly at museums, but also at some theaters as well. Bigger movie theaters, however, did not change their ticket prices.

  • foto
    ETV to air British miniseries 'Tutankhamun'
    07.01

    2016 British historical drama "Tutankhamun," which will bring the search for the famous Egyptian pharaoh to its viewers, will kick off on ETV beginning on Saturday night.

  • foto
    Hendrik Kaljujärv's meaning-layered 'Overexposure'
    06.01

    In addition to recommendations, Culture.ee's English-language culture blog also provides reviews of musical, theatrical, dance and other cultural performances that take place around Estonia. In this review, Anneliis Lepp reflects on how the visuals, music as well as layers of meaning played important roles in an end of the year production of Hendrik Kaljujärv's play "Overexposure."

  • foto
    Ilona Gurjanova, Andrus Kõresaar 2016 winners of Foreign Ministry's annual culture awards
    05.01

    Estonian Minister of Foreign Affairs Sven Mikser presented the ministry's 2016 Culture Awards to Estonian Association of Designers chairman Ilona Gurjanova and KOKO Architects founder Andrus Kõresaar on Wednesday.

  • foto
    Kaspar Jancis animated short 'Piano' wins award at international festival in St. Petersburg
    22.12

    The animated short film "Piano" won a special jury prize at the 14th International Festival of Animation Arts "Multivision" in St. Petersburg.

  • foto
    Toomas Hussar's 'The Spy and the Poet' selected for Palm Springs Film Festival
    21.12

    Toomas Hussar's 2016 feature film "The Spy and the Poet" has been selected for the official program of the international Palm Springs Film Festival, which has previously included other Estonian coproductions such as "Tangerines" and "The Fencer" in its lineup. PSFF will also mark the new film's North American premiere.

  • foto
    Culture.ee's weekly recommendations: Holiday edition
    19.12

    Weekly recommendations for cultural events taking place in Estonia this week as curated by and published in the Culture critics’ blog at culture.ee: "The holiday season is upon us and there is no escaping it, so one may as well enjoy it! We at culture.ee wish you all a joyous week!"

  • foto
    The anthropological documentarian in a world of bite-sized narratives
    2016

    "The Measure of Humanity: 45 Years of Documentary Photography in South Africa" at Adamson-Eric Museum in Tallinn presents a comprehensive overview of the career of the recently deceased South African photographer Juhan Kuus.

  • foto
    Culture.ee's weekly recommendations: Dec. 12-18
    2016

    Weekly recommendations for cultural events taking place in Estonia this week as curated by and published in the Culture critics’ blog at culture.ee: "We hope they offer you amusement, but also themes to think about. Have a wonderful week!"

  • foto
    2017 Grammy nominees include multiple Estonians
    2016

    The nominees for the 59. Grammy Awards were published on Tuesday, and upon closer inspection the list included both better- and lesser-known Estonian names and involved an Estonian music label, a number of Estonian musical ensembles and works by an Estonian composer as well.

  • foto
    Culture.ee's weekly recommendations: Dec. 5-11
    2016

    Weekly recommendations for cultural events taking place in Estonia this week as curated by and published in the Culture critics’ blog at culture.ee: "Places to be, things to do, exhibitions to enjoy, concerts to attend and dances to dance. Keep warm and take in all the great experiences!"

  • foto
    Culture.ee's weekly recommendations: Nov. 28-Dec. 4
    2016

    Weekly recommendations for cultural events taking place in Estonia this week as curated by and published in the Culture critics’ blog at culture.ee. It seems as though the Christmas spirit is nearby, because this week offers plenty of music and merry gatherings.

  • foto
    Estonian choir's concert series focuses on life, work of poet Lydia Koidula
    2016

    130 years following her death, the award-winning Youth Mixed Choir Vox Populi will be giving a short series of concert-lectures dedicated to the life of the famous Estonian poet Lydia Koidula at schools and cultural centers across the country in an alternative to more typical holiday-themed Advent-season performances.

  • foto
    'A Quiet Heart' wins international award at Estonia's Black Nights Film Festival
    2016

    Eitan Anner's "A Quiet Heart" ("Lev Shaket") was awarded the Grand Prix of the 20th Black Nights Film Festival (PÖFF) at the festival's awards ceremony in Tallinn on Saturday night.

  • foto
    Interview with Yaniv Berman, director of PÖFF film 'Land of the Little People'
    2016

    Helina Koldek of culture.ee interviewed Yaniv Berman, director of 2016 Israeli film "Land of the Little People," one of the films featured in the 2016 program of Estonia's Black Nights Film Festival (PÖFF).

  • foto
    Culture.ee's weekly recommendations: Nov. 21-27
    2016

    Weekly recommendations for cultural events taking place in Estonia this week as curated by and published in the Culture critics’ blog at culture.ee. Here is a diverse and bold choice of events for the ongoing week. Open your minds and have a great time!

  • foto
    10 recommendations for Black Nights Film Festival
    2016

    The 20th annual Black Nights Film Festival, better known by Estonian acronym PÖFF, is already in full swing, with a rich program of screenings at various locations in Tallinn and Tartu. As the number and variety of films on offer may be overwhelming for festivalgoers, Helina Koldek of culture.ee has shared her top ten picks for this year's edition of PÖFF.

  • foto
    Renovation of Song Festival Grounds to start after 2019
    2016

    The Riigikogu’s Cultural Affairs Committee on Monday supported a plan to renovate the stage of the Song Festival Grounds in Tallinn as well as the surrounding buildings. According to MP Laine Randjärv (Reform), who chairs the committee, construction could begin after the next Song Festival in 2019.

  • foto
    Culture.ee's weekly recommendations: Nov. 14-20
    2016

    Weekly recommendations for cultural events taking place in Estonia this week as curated by and published in the Culture critics’ blog at culture.ee. November in Estonia is always associated with the Black Nights Film Festival (PÖFF), but in addition to this wonderful event, there are plenty of others as well. Have a great week!

  • foto
    Culture.ee's weekly recommendations: Nov. 7-13
    2016

    Weekly recommendations for cultural events taking place in Estonia this week as curated by and published in the Culture critics’ blog at culture.ee. We have a busy week ahead of us! In addition to the annual film festival PÖFF, there will also be another interesting film program, lots of stimulating music, a big fair and even an international poetry slam. Stay warm and enjoy!

  • foto
    Benno Schirrmeister: Do Estonians dream of electric sheep?
    2016

    On a journalist exchange in Estonia, Benno Schirrmeister of Bremen’s TAZ is highly informed, yet a blank slate as far as a foreigner’s experience of Estonia is concerned. In his first op-ed about Tallinn, he spots something beyond IT that Estonia could advertise — but doesn’t.

  • foto
    VIDEO: Kristjan Randalu Trio performs with American guitarist Ben Monder
    2016

    On Oct. 31 and Nov. 1, the Kristjan Randalu Trio played four concerts over two nights with American modern jazz guitarist Ben Monder, who has both released solo albums as well as been featured on hundreds of other albums, including David Bowie's final album "Blackstar" (2016).

  • foto
    Culture.ee's weekly recommendations: Oct. 31-Nov. 6
    2016

    Weekly recommendations for cultural events taking place in Estonia this week as curated by and published in the Culture critics’ blog at culture.ee. A great week lies ahead filled with interesting performances, dazzling dance acts and cinematography.

  • foto
    Estonian art magazine's 2016 issue to be celebrated with public launch party
    2016

    Estonian Art is an English-language art magazine published by the Estonian Institute since 1997; its 2016 issue, the launch for which will be celebrated at the Contemporary Art Museum of Estonia in Tallinn on Friday night, focuses on art publishing in Estonia.